The second administration of U.S. Pres. Donald Trump has begun cracking down on immigration, abruptly shortening temporary protective status for Haitians and others fleeing violence, and is now trying to deport a well-known Palestinian rights activist at Columbia University – with threats to cancel visas of many more. How is this news shaping the views of students and graduates around the world who have helped fund America’s colleges and universities in Boston and beyond through tuition? Our Sampan reporter based in Hong Kong found out by interviewing a number of people who either recently returned from the U.S. or are considering studying here. Some students only wanted their first names used or to remain anonymous.

Shawn (Last name withheld), Northwestern University graduate, living in Hong Kong, age 25:
Despite American foreign policy that emphasizes isolationism and a growing proclivity toward anti-immigration, I think it’s important to consider the different effects these policies have on different types of immigrants or foreigners. For international students living in America the effects will not be as adverse compared to expat workers because, first, the overall university and academic climate is very left-leaning in a lot of places and are often against current federal policies, which makes universities a comparatively safer space and, second, students have less lobbying power than workers, and there is, as a result, less of a narrative or push against international students “taking university spots” as opposed to taking jobs, which makes international students less of a target, so it doesn’t affect my opinion of the U.S. as much. I would be interested in a cost-benefit analysis to see how valuable an American university education is compared to the possible discrimination internationals might face in their future.

(Name withheld) Current high school student, living in Korea, age 18:
The Trump administration’s policies have made me more cautious about studying in the U.S., but they have not deterred me from pursuing my education there. While concerns about visa restrictions and shifting immigration policies exist, I would still like to believe that the U.S. is a top destination for academic and professional growth. American universities offer unparalleled opportunities, and I believe that the long-term benefits of studying in the U.S. outweigh the uncertainties caused by political fluctuations. I remain hopeful that international students will continue to be valued for the diversity and perspectives they bring to U.S. campuses.

Justin Kondozim, High school student, Togo, age 19:
I am increasingly concerned about the recent rumors and policies from the Trump administration regarding the potential removal of scholarships for international students. As a child growing up in Togo, where educational resources and job opportunities are limited, pursuing my studies in the U.S. has always been a dream. My goal is to acquire knowledge and skills to help develop my country upon my return. However, the fear of deportation and obstacles in applying for scholarships make me hesitant. I have considered alternatives like Canada, but tuition costs are prohibitive, and scholarships are scarce. Balancing the need for a quality education against these challenges feels like an overwhelming dilemma.

Aadi Avlani, High school student of Indian descent, living in Hong Kong, age 17:
I’ve always envisioned myself living in the United States, whether for university, work, or eventually settling down. Surprisingly, the current Trump administration feels more like an opportunity than a drawback to me. While Trump as a person may not be everyone’s favorite, he managed to win the majority in the most recent election, and I’m intrigued to understand why that happened. I’d love to explore the factors behind the significant shift toward right-wing ideologies in the U.S. and what’s driving this change, and the best way to do that is just to be within that area. What excites me most is the unconventional approach Trump brings to politics. My curiosity has grown since the election, drawing me even more toward the U.S. and away from other countries like the U.K. For me, the political climate in the U.S. right now makes it a much more appealing place.

(Name withheld), High school student, Pakistan, age 18:
Although Trump has implemented many radical policies and shifts, I have always looked toward the U.S. as the ideal country for higher education. Both my siblings currently reside in the U.S., therefore it is also more convenient for me to study there. I would also like to work in the U.S. in the future, therefore getting a U.S. education seems to make more sense. However, I have received some offers and scholarships from countries like the U.K. and Canada, which is immensely cheaper than a U.S. education. Cost is quite a large factor in my education, so I will likely wait and see what offers I will get in the U.S. and what their financial aid packages look like. Nevertheless, Trump’s administration does not play too large a role in my decision.

Miguel Vasquez, High school student, ethnically El Salvadorian, living in Hong Kong, age 17:
As a 17-year-old living in Hong Kong with Salvadoran nationality, the process of applying to universities in the U.S. feels both exciting and uncertain. As someone who has lived in the U.S. for nine years because of my dad’s diplomatic work, I’ve developed a fond appreciation of the opportunities and diversity the U.S. offers. However, I have only lived in the U.S. under the Obama and Biden administration, hence the current administration’s policies and rhetoric make me somewhat nervous, especially regarding visas and discrimination towards the Latinx community (which fortunately I have never faced before). Although the U.S. is still my first option, I am looking at other possibilities like Spain and the U.K., where I am not only closer to my parents, but also where immigration policies appear to be more secure. What I ultimately want is to study in a place where I can feel safe and supported with no interruption to my education, and I hope the U.S. will be able to provide me with that.

Callista (last name withheld), University student, Norway, age 20:
It makes me not want to study in the U.S. Trump is quite unpredictable and I have not seen it as a safe environment through social media. It has also stopped me from wanting to pursue a job there. I have considered other options like U.K., which I see as equally good and Australia, but I was already considering this due to other drawbacks of the U.S. system.